changesIn
ChatGPTUse changesIn to see which articles of an act, or of a part, title, chapter or section of it, changed and when. Pass "OR" or "Zehnter Titel: Der Arbeitsvertrag OR" and you get one entry per date and per article whose words changed, each marked as reworded, added or removed, with citations that open the article before and after the change via resolve. Pass since with the date you last looked, or the date of a decision or a contract, to get only the changes that came into force after it, including those adopted but not yet in force. A call on a whole act compares every article of it across every version, which is a lot of work. Ask about the narrowest unit that covers your question, and pass since where you have a date. For a single article, history lists the same changes together with the article's versions and their windows. An empty list means no change within the covered versions, not a guarantee that nothing changed before coverage begins.
citationsTo
ChatGPTUse citationsTo to check how an authority has been received. You have an article or a decision, and you get the current decisions, commentaries, and other sources that cite it. This is the recency check on a decisive authority: newer citing decisions can confirm, narrow, distinguish, or reject it. It is also a direct route from a provision to the case law applying it: pass "Art. 29 Abs. 2 BV" and read the decisions that interpreted it, or add restrictToDocumentType=commentary for commentary that cites it. Where you need the purpose of a provision, add restrictToDocumentType=parliamentaryMaterials: the passages of the Federal Council's dispatch and of the committee reports that discuss that article can come back the same way, and they carry that purpose in the words of those who proposed it. Check citations precisely: ask for citations to "Art. 108 OR" or "BGE 145 II 229 E. 7.4", never to an act as a whole, because citations attach to articles and considerations. A leading case may be cited by its BGE reference or by its docket number. Both count. Filters narrow the citing side (only cantonal decisions, only decisions since 2020) and each one hides every citing source outside it, so set them deliberately, not by default. The result is reading material, not a verdict: no citations does not mean uncontested. Read each citing decision to see whether it supports or undermines the authority. Citing sources also do different work: one may state the rule, a factually closer one may carry its application. Read them for their function, not as duplicates. When a citing source merely characterizes the target, or rests its rule on an older leading case, follow the citation to the original with resolve, and cite the original for the point its own passage supports. If citationsTo returns little on a decisive authority, searching its citation is a further option: sources sometimes discuss an authority without citing it in a recognizable form.
findIn
ChatGPTUse findIn when you know the source but not the place: which consideration of a known decision deals with your issue, where an act regulates a point, where a commentary discusses it. Name the source or the part to search ("BGE 145 II 229", "OR", "Art. 108 OR") and say what you are looking for as you would to a colleague. The same call serves the moment an act has just given you a claim, a permit, or a competence: ask that act for its reservation, exclusion, and subsidiarity clauses, because they often stand apart from the granting provision and say where the act withholds what it grants. Matching is by meaning, so an empty result does not prove the words are absent. To verify a literal quote, a term of art, or a coined formula, set matching=exact: it finds passages carrying that wording, tolerant of spelling and spacing variants. Read the matched passage. The reading verifies the quote, not the match, and a meaning-based match never anchors exact wording. If exact finds nothing, drop back to the default meaning-based matching on the proposition and read what it finds: the source may phrase the point differently. Either way, results identify places to read, not conclusions: where the matched passage lacks the context that qualifies it, open the passages around it or the unit that holds it before building on it. resolve of the matched pinpoint names them in its navigation. findIn always searches current searchable text. Use history and dated resolve for older law. resolve may list a known version it cannot open. An empty match list does not establish that a law or its historical version lacks text.
history
ChatGPTUse history to check whether the provision behind an older authority changed, or to see which act version was in force on a date relevant to past facts. Reach for it before you state a rule that a judgment took from a provision as the law today. A judgment applies the wording that governed its facts, and that wording may have changed since, or may already have been replaced when the judgment was given: a recent judgment on an earlier period often marks this with "aArt." or "(in der bis 31. Dezember 2020 geltenden Fassung)". history lists an article's versions, each with its validity window and a citation that opens it via resolve, and the dated substantive amendments. Where both versions are available, resolve the before-and-after citations and compare them. A change to the part that carries the rule can make it a rule of the earlier version, to be stated with that version: the revised act and what the case law says of it decide. A change elsewhere in the article can leave it standing. To answer "has Art. 336c OR changed since this 2015 decision?", pass "Art. 336c OR" and check for amendments after that date. Then use citationsTo on the decision to check whether later case law still carries its holding. To find the version in force in 2019, open the listed version whose window covers it. Where a matter spans periods, establish the version for each phase separately rather than assuming one period's law carries into another. history shows the candidate versions and their windows: which one governs is a further question, turning on the transitional provisions (findIn the act for them) and the legally material event. history works on acts only, at article level: ask about the article, not the whole act, to see per-provision changes. An empty change list means no amendment within the covered versions, not a guarantee the provision never changed. For periods before coverage begins, decisions of the era often quote the text they applied: find them via citationsTo on the provision or a date-bounded search. Where the earliest version history lists starts after the facts of the judgment you are checking, the list cannot show which wording the judgment applied, since that start can be where coverage of the act begins rather than a change. Then resolve the article and read its footnotes: a date of entry into force there ("in Kraft seit 1. Jan. 2021", "en vigueur depuis le 1er janv. 2021") dates the current wording of the article or of its paragraph. Where that date falls after the judgment's facts, the judgment may have applied an earlier wording: the judgment itself and the act's transitional provisions show which, so check that and compare the part that carries the rule with today's text before you state the rule as the law today. Where a judgment itself describes what a revision changed, earlier case law on those points may be law of the earlier version: what that judgment says of it, and the revised act, decide. What governs now is read in the revised act, which can place it in another article than the one the judgment applied: findIn the act on the situation in its own words, then resolve the provision it finds.
resolve
ChatGPTUse resolve to read the law itself: give it a citation ("Art. 336c OR", "art. 336c al. 1 CO", "BGE 145 II 229 E. 7.4", "4A_610/2018", "SR 220") and you get the exact text with its structure, and the references of the passages around it. Open a known citation directly instead of searching for it. And read before you cite: a headnote is an editorial summary, an excerpt lacks the context that qualifies it, and memory of wording is not a source. Read acts at article level even when a single paragraph is cited: an article's paragraphs and clauses belong together. Check the neighboring articles through the returned table of contents, because scope rules, exceptions, and consequences of the same regime often sit side by side. Read decisions at the level of the consideration that carries your point, in its procedural context (facts, the decision under appeal, the scope of review). Where a pinpoint needs more context to be read properly, read around it: each passage resolve returns names in navigation the unit that contains it and the passages before and after it within that unit, so at the first or last passage of a unit the step beyond goes through the unit above. Each of those references opens with resolve, as does a passage the pinpoint itself cites for its point. Where a decision is published, open the published designation ("BGE 145 II 229", "BVGE 2013/51") rather than its docket number, so you read the text in its official published form. The authorities whose facts and reasoning carry the assessment warrant reading in full. Check who is speaking and what was decided: only the court's own reasoning is a holding. A party's submission, a lower court's view, a point expressly left open, or silence on a point is not. Cantonal acts want the canton in the citation ("§ 309 PBG/ZH"). If an abbreviation exists in several cantons, say which one you mean, or search first. resolve serves the current version by default. effectiveOn opens the version in force on a given date. If an older version is unavailable, find decisions from when it was in force, via citationsTo on the provision or a date-bounded search. They often quote the provision they applied. Do not silently substitute today's text.
resolveCitations
ChatGPTUse resolveCitations on a text that already contains citations (a brief, a decision, a memo, a draft), before you rely on the text. resolveCitations binds each citation it recognizes to its verified source and returns the source with its passage, so you can check that the text's propositions match what the sources actually say. Citing is not self-executing: a source supports only what its read passage supports. This also works on retrieved decisions: bind the authorities a judgment cites before adopting its characterization of them. Pass citationContextDate as the date the text was written. Citations then open the version in force at that date ("Art. 471 ZGB" in a 2022 will opens the 2022 text), and relative forms like "aArt. 336c OR" resolve against it. A qualifier written in the text, such as "(Fassung vom ...)", always wins. Which version legally governs the matter is a further question: the date only fixes what the citation opens. resolveCitations binds only what is written in the text. It is not a search. For authorities on a question, use search. A citation that does not resolve leaves the source unverified in both directions: check it by hand. A large batch is served in less depth than a single read. Each resolved citation gets a share of one fixed response-wide structural allowance, and a citation whose structure exceeds its share is served as the passages the text budget funded plus the units containing them. The share decides which citations are cut back, not how much of each survives, so a large batch can come back well under the allowance. Passages the text budget funded are always kept. Where structure was withheld the response says so, at response level with sourceStructureOmittedDueToBatchAllocation, and on each affected node with subtreeOmittedDueToBatchAllocation, whose childCount states how many children that unit has. resolve that citation's reference to read it in full. Cite from what you have actually read, not from a heading you were shown.
search
ChatGPTUse search to find the authorities you do not yet have: the governing provision, the leading cases, commentary, parliamentary materials, or administrative practice on a question. Phrase the query as you would state the issue to a colleague. For fact-driven questions, add one or two concrete facts that a judgment would mention: doctrine alone can miss the factually closest decisions, and facts alone can miss the doctrine. Searching works in all official languages. A query in the source's own language stays closest to its legal terminology, so write it in the language of the mandate or of the source you are looking for. The ECtHR collection holds English and French text only, so query it in one of those two languages. Search covers current searchable text. An empty result establishes neither the absence of a law nor the absence of a historical version or its text. Identify earlier and ended law through history and resolve. A known version may be listed even where resolve cannot open it. Search everything by default: filters narrow what is searched, so set one only when the source you are looking for is itself confined to that slice. Where cantonal law can decide the question (public personnel, cantonal taxes, building and planning, social assistance, schools, police), a canton-restricted search brings up cantonal sources that federal material can otherwise push down the list. Keep the federal search canton-free, because the canton filter excludes all federal sources. restrictToDocumentType makes the search a deliberate sweep through one family of sources: acts when decisions crowd out the statutory basis, parliamentary materials for legislative purpose, administrative practice for implementation, commentary for interpretation. Every result carries an exact citation. Hand it on as returned: to resolve to read a text the result does not carry, to look up a reference it cites, or to move to the passage above, before, or after it and gather the context a proper reading of it needs (resolve of the matched pinpoint names, in its navigation, the passages before and after it and the unit that holds it), to findIn to locate the passage, to citationsTo to check how it has been received, to history to check for amendments. Each result also carries a link to the source on justement.ch, for a reader who wants to open it: the link opens the source the result cites, which can be broader than the matched passage, and for a source not published on the site it lands on a search page for the citation. The other methods take the citation, not the link. The same decision can appear both under its docket number and under its published designation ("BGE", "BVGE"). Work from the published designation: publication marks the leading case, and the published text carries the official framing that the bare docket text can lack. If your text already contains citations, bind them with resolveCitations instead of searching for them. A result that carries a passage's text carries it whole, and that passage is read: rely on it or dismiss it from that text, with the context around it where reading it properly needs more. A headnote, and a result whose text was omitted, are leads: read the passage itself before you rely on it, and before you dismiss it. An empty or thin result means this framing found nothing, not that nothing exists. Results follow the framing of the query, and coverage differs by court, canton, and period. To surface more, change the framing rather than the phrasing: - another vocabulary register: the statutory term, the doctrinal label, or the concrete facts - another route: resolve the suspected provision and its neighbors, findIn inside the likely act, citationsTo on the governing article - another official language, if the source plausibly lives in it or its wording could decide the point Near-identical queries mostly return the same results. Report a negative as what it is: nothing found for these framings, never proof that no authority exists.
changesIn
ClaudecitationsTo
ClaudefindIn
Claudehistory
Clauderesolve
ClauderesolveCitations
Claudesearch
Claude